I’ve been a proponent of watching movies by myself for the past year. Not many of my friends are into foreign films or art house films. Thats ok. I go to the theater alone.
Last night, however, my roomate David showed me something so obvious, so basic, about watching and experiencing art that I must question my theater-going.
One of the big reasons that I loved Aronofsky’s The Wrestler was its ending. It was nothing new or groundbreaking, but then again, nothing about the film was. Instead, it followed many other recent masterpieces by rolling the credits before a full resolution or denouement. We get the climax, feel good (or bad) and leave the theater.
And I loved The Wrestler because of its happy ending. Randy “The Ram” ends the movie (and his life?) doing what he loves. Flying. Wrestling. Bringing smiles to the faces of the people he cares the most about, his fans.
I truly believe that we are entering, slowly, a decade of beautiful and hopeful art. I thought, after watching Rourke’s brilliance fly over the camera in the last scene, that this depressing story’s happy ending was heralding this shift in art. I still think it was.
But David didn’.
He was saddened by the ending. He called it depressing. He sat on the couch and stared at the screen the way you would after watching this movie.
He wasn’t inspired.
David and I discussed (something you cant do after doing theater-solo) about the happiness and sadness of the ending. I enjoyed it, and saw it as hopeful because Randy chooses what he loves, fans and performance, over the other things in his life, even if they are better (family and love). David disagreed– though he chose what he loved, they were fake things: a fake performance anchored on a fake persona.
Where I loved the movie for showing a man doing what he loved, David was disappointed that the man lived and loved a lie.
If we are happy, does it matter that we believe in a lie? The Wrestler probes this question. It’s about truth. And love. And the ability for both of these things to exist out side of the other.



